Retired Police Officer Appeals Conviction Over Reposted Facebook Meme

England abolished blasphemy laws, but this appeal asks whether they found another route back.

British police officer looking at a targeted red speech bubble against a Union Jack and the UK Parliament.

If you’re tired of censorship and surveillance, subscribe to Reclaim The Net.

A retired British police officer who served for 27 years with Cleveland Police has asked a UK court to overturn his conviction for reposting a Facebook meme.

The defendant, 65-year-old Stephen Gray from Darlington, appeared before Teesside Crown Court in Middlesbrough on Friday, November 13, to try to get the conviction quashed.

The ruling he is trying to overturn was handed down on April 30 by District Judge Steven Hood at Newton Aycliffe Magistrates’ Court. Gray was found guilty under section 127(1)(a) of the Communications Act 2003, which makes it an offense to send “by means of a public electronic communications network a message or other matter that is grossly offensive or of an indecent, obscene or menacing character.”

For this, Gray was ordered to pay over £1,000 in fines and costs.

The offending meme shows a strip of bacon and a man in a turban, with the caption, “Fun facts about Bacon! People who eat bacon have a lower chance of marrying a 9-year-old!”

The prosecution was brought despite the fact that the post was not created by Gray, but merely reposted, and despite the fact that the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) initially declined to take the case, finding no realistic prospect of conviction.

That decision was made after Gray’s next-door neighbor, Alexander Kurlandzki, who is not a Muslim, went to the police in January 2025. Gray then told the police that the report was “malicious” and that the motive behind it was to get him a criminal record so he could no longer foster children, given his previous disagreements with the neighbor.

Kurlandzki then used the Victims’ Right to Review scheme, which the CPS describes as covering decisions “not to start a prosecution or to stop a prosecution,” and the CPS then changed its mind and decided to prosecute.

Gray was charged over two of his reposts, but Hood acquitted him of one, which said it was “time for mass deportation” – this was seen as a political issue that is being debated in Parliament. The second post, the “bacon meme” was, however, viewed as targeting a religion, and not politics.

During the original trial, prosecutors presented the court with other Facebook posts by Gray, that had to do with his criticism of the Labour Party and its leader, Keir Starmer, “for context.”

The Free Speech Union, who is supporting Gray’s appeal, said that the judge found the post could not have been making a serious point “because it was framed in a light-hearted way,” and that convicting him was not a disproportionate interference with his freedom of expression.

The Free Speech Union, who are supporting Gray, disagree, and say that “satire has always been one of the most effective ways of making a serious point,” and that “a joke is not disqualified from saying something important merely because it is a joke.”

During the appeal hearing, Gray was asked by his barrister, John Beggs KC, why he shared the post, and he replied: “To bring to light what is not a very nice part of what goes on in this country – child marriage, forced marriage and just the way some children are treated.” He said he felt “very strongly” about it: “I have two daughters, I fostered three girls.” and “I look at these girls and I think they could be married (young) or abused and it doesn’t sit happily with me.”

Shada Mellor, for the CPS, suggested that the post was referring to all people of Islamic faith, and that an ex-policeman must have known that such posts could whip up tension.

Gray disagreed, and said that he was not referring to all Muslims, but to the prophet.

Mellor asked him if he was aware that his posts could be shared more widely than his 15-20 followers, and in her closing remarks, she said that while people are entitled to make comments, “the question is, does this post cross the threshold into ‘grossly offensive’?”

Beggs, on the other hand, said in his closing remarks: “we are entitled to be offensive in this country, because we live in a liberal democracy that has plurality and democracy.”

Recorder Bryan Cox, sitting with two magistrates, reserved judgment, with the result of the appeal expected on December 21.

In the meantime, the Free Speech Union, who is supporting Gray, has been vocal in its criticism of the case and the law that made it possible, saying that Parliament abolished blasphemy offenses in England and Wales in 2008, and that they “should not return through the back door.”

After the hearing, the organization said, “Today has once again shown that the process itself is the punishment.”

Earlier, Gray said, “I made a joke, an ironic joke, about Islam.” And “I just think it’s a dangerous road that the Government is going down trying to use the justice system to get us to stop criticising a religion that promotes a lot of things people might not agree with.”

Reclaim The Net has covered the case when the conviction happened, noting that “English comedy has acquired paperwork” and that while “Parliament supplied the adjectives; Hood supplied the boundary between political and religious mockery.”

We also covered a Big Brother Watch report that said police made at least 62,199 arrests over five years under section 127 and similar communications laws, with 12,292 people being convicted.

In 2024 the Court of Appeal ruled in the Casserly case that political context must play a prominent role in deciding what counts as “grossly offensive.” But the law remains on the books and is still being applied – and it is up to the courts to decide whether its application in individual cases is legitimate.

The case of the “bacon meme” is yet another in a long list of examples of how section 127 is used to stifle online speech – and it’s a stark reminder that the law, and its interpretation, is overly broad and open to abuse, and should be abolished.

If you’re tired of censorship and surveillance, subscribe to Reclaim The Net.