UK Minister Asked Google to Remove Russell Brand Channel

Russell Brand says he’s not guilty. The government’s response was to ask Google to delete the channel he said it on.

Russell Brand with a butterfly sticker on his forehead poses for a selfie with his wife Laura Gallacher.

If you’re tired of censorship and surveillance, subscribe to Reclaim The Net.

It turns out that a UK government minister went to Google and asked it to remove Russell Brand’s YouTube channel, because his wife, during their joint Sunday Service show, read a message from him, sent from prison, where he said he was not guilty.

Brand was convicted this month of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault, and jailed for 10 years and six months.

But when his wife Laura read out his message from prison, that he is “not guilty of the offenses I have been jailed for,” a convicted man who is appealing his own sentence and stating his plea was too much for the British government to stomach.

Ministers are not only in the business of locking people up for opinions, but also, it seems, in that of making sure they cannot express their opinions, even if it means going to Google, in a private meeting, to ask the tech giant to take down an entire channel.

This is according to a report by Sky News, which said Google had been contacted for comment, while the channel was still up at the time of the report and sources say that Google declined the government's request to delete Brand's channel.

And so we have a situation where a minister goes to a private company to ask for censorship of a citizen.

The channel has 6.6 million subscribers, and the video was posted on November 15, as part of the couple’s weekly Sunday Service show, which Laura Brand presented alone, reading from the message.

Justice Secretary Alex Norris took to X to say, “The broadcast of a statement from Russell Brand is completely unacceptable. Prisoners are rightly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims. This is being urgently investigated, and I expect action to be taken if he is found to have broken the rules.”

Norris turned off his replies so no one could respond.

Post from Alex Norris MP calling the broadcast of a statement from Russell Brand completely unacceptable.

Prisoners have the right to appeal, as reports note that Brand is expected to do.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s spokesperson said, “This is clearly appalling and is being urgently investigated,” and “Prisoners cannot get around these rules by having someone else publish their comments.”

And then there’s Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, who had this to say: “No remorse, no sympathy for the victims. Just disgusting comments.”

After all this, a minister went to Google.

The Ministry of Justice does not comment on individual cases, but it can raise issues of content with social media platforms.

And an investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules by having his message read out was already under way – but the Ministry’s request to Google seems to be an extra, separate step.

And, the prison service’s own media rules, PSI 37/2010, re-issued in December 2023, state that correspondence from prisoners intended for “posting on the Internet” must not contain material about their own crime – “except where it consists of serious representations about conviction or sentence.”

In other words, the rules allow for a prisoner to dispute their conviction – and it is up to the prison to decide whether Brand’s message falls into that category, and impose a punishment if it doesn’t. But the decision to go to Google came from a minister.

Earlier, Meta disabled Brand’s Instagram and Facebook accounts after the conviction, citing a policy of restricting or removing accounts that may be “harmful” – including those of convicted sex offenders.

And YouTube cut off his earnings in 2023, before he had even been charged with any wrongdoing, using the excuse that “if a creator’s off-platform behavior harms our users, employees or ecosystem, we take action.”

It’s also not the first time the British authorities have gone to social media platforms to try to silence Brand: in September 2023, the Commons culture committee chair, Dame Caroline Dinenage, wrote to Rumble asking if it would “join YouTube in suspending Mr Brand’s ability to earn money on the platform.” Rumble responded at the time by rejecting the request, while X told the committee it does not take action against accounts that have not violated its rules or local laws.

The Ministry of Justice has no business going to Google, or any other private company, and asking it to censor speech. The prison service can deal with any breach of its rules, and that does not include asking a private company to erase a channel. But then, this is a government that has shown it is more than willing to work with private censorship.

If you’re tired of censorship and surveillance, subscribe to Reclaim The Net.