The popular YouTube channel Black Pigeon Speaks has been suddenly scrubbed from YouTube just one day after it posted a video calling out Vox host Carlos Maza for his role in the latest YouTube adpocalypse. The channel was fully monetized and had no strikes but this didn’t prevent it from being caught up in the recent rise of questionable channel terminations that have occurred during this new adpocalypse.
The Black Pigeon Speaks YouTube channel had 489,000+ subscribers (archive link) when it was banned and focused on a range of topics including history, urbanism, and politics. Black Pigeon Speaks often called out censorship and SJWs in his videos but took great care to not violate any of YouTube’s rules.
Ironically, in his final YouTube video which was posted yesterday, Black Pigeon Speaks criticized Vox host Carlo Maza for pressuring YouTube to take action against comedian Steven Crowder. YouTube introduced new “hate speech” rules after Maza’s complaints about Crowder led to his channel being demonetized and these new “hate speech” rules are now causing numerous channels to be demonetized or banned.
Black Pigeon Speaks also appears to have been banned due to these new “hate speech” rules with some people reportedly receiving the following message when attempting to access his channel:
“This account has been terminated due to multiple or severe violations of YouTube's policy prohibiting hate speech.”
"This account has been terminated due to multiple or severe violations of YouTube's policy prohibiting hate speech." pic.twitter.com/wAV6OWeMkx
— Cynical Sceptic 🇷🇸 (@CynicalSceptic_) June 13, 2019
Black Pigeon Speaks confirmed that his YouTube channel had been terminated on Twitter and said that YouTube had given no reason for the ban.
@TeamYouTube This must be a mistake. My channel had videos on history, urbanism, transporation, travel, festival as well as political content. Please rectify this mistake or at least tell me what was the reason. https://t.co/q5BpD7uV6B
— BPS (@navyhato) June 13, 2019
Team YouTube did respond on Twitter and said that Black Pigeon Speaks can appeal the decision but didn’t clarify why the channel was terminated in the first place.
We'd like to help. You should've received an email regarding the termination offering more details. Also, if you think it happened in error, you can always appeal. Here's how: https://t.co/NQRWQe1uqt . Let us know how it goes.
— TeamYouTube (@TeamYouTube) June 13, 2019
The removal of Black Pigeon Speaks YouTube channel is the latest in a series of strange channel terminations that have taken place under YouTube’s new “hate speech” rules. The new rules allow YouTube to remove content based on subjective labels such as “hateful,” “harmful,” and “borderline” and this has led to history teachers, independent journalists, and other seemingly innocuous channels being removed from the site. After introducing the new rules, YouTube even admitted that creators can be punished, even if they don’t violate community guidelines.
Many people are outraged by YouTube’s decision to take down Black Pigeon Speaks and see it as an example of YouTube’s continued corporate censorship of “wrong think.”
Black Pigeon Speaks' @navyhato YT channel has been completely terminated!!!
This is terrifying when it comes to the affects this has on freedom of speech and looks like only the beginning of “wrong think” censorship by the corporate state.
— Luke Rudkowski (@Lukewearechange) June 13, 2019
YouTube banned a vegan dude who rescued pigeons and produced carefully worded content specifically designed not to violate their TOS. No reason given.
Ludicrous and proof of flagrant partisan censorship of conservatives.
RT if you think @TeamYouTube should restore his account.
— Paul Joseph Watson (@PrisonPlanet) June 13, 2019
Black Pigeon Speaks has been Banned https://t.co/7kql0fdjw6 Get your favorite creators to speak out about this, if they can get someone like BPS who was very careful to stay within YouTube's ever tightening set of rules they can get anyone #UnbanBPS
— BitChute 🎃 (@bitchute) June 13, 2019
Update – June 14, 2019: The Black Pigeon Speaks YouTube channel been reinstated.