Clicky

Resist censorship. Reject surveillance. Reclaim your voice.

Support the exposure of censorship and surveillance, and protect your digital rights:

Resist censorship. Reject surveillance. Reclaim your voice.

Support the exposure of censorship and surveillance, and protect your digital rights:

Lawyer comments on the YouTubers who said they’ve copyrighted every melody

The YouTubers created 68.7 billion melodies.

If you’re tired of censorship and surveillance, join Reclaim The Net.

Last summer, a California jury decided that pop star Katy Perryโ€™s song โ€œDark Horseโ€ infringed on the copyright of Christian hip-hop artist Flameโ€™s 2008 song โ€œJoyful Noise.โ€

Perry and her writers and producers โ€“ who were ordered to pay $2.8 million in damages โ€“ said the ruling was โ€œa travesty of justiceโ€ as they couldnโ€™t have infringed โ€“ having neither access nor creating a work of substantial similarity.

Many commented on the juryโ€™s decision as a potentially dangerous precedent that could bog down the music industry in copyright chaos.

Among them was YouTuber and musician Adam Neely, who later set out to create an experiment together with Damien Riehl and Noah Rubin, and share it in a video entitled, โ€œEvery Melody Has Been Copyrighted (and theyโ€™re all on this hard drive.โ€

Click here to display content from YouTube.
Learn more in YouTubeโ€™s privacy policy.

They said the drive in question contained 2.6 terabytes of compressed data consisting of 68.7 billion copyrighted melodies.

And since โ€œevery melodyโ€ has thus been copyrighted โ€“ now what?

Asking that question was the purpose of the video, as itโ€™s revealed at the end โ€“ itโ€™s an attempt to โ€œthrow a wrenchโ€ into the whole copyright protection process as it is today, in the hope of highlighting its shortcomings.

But another YouTuber, lawyer Leonard French, added his two cents to the conversation โ€“ from the purely legal standpoint.

His video โ€“ โ€œNo, Every Melody Has Not Been Copyrightedโ€- aims to explain what Neely, Riehl and Rubin have actually done.

Click here to display content from YouTube.
Learn more in YouTubeโ€™s privacy policy.

For one thing, French said, they havenโ€™t succeeded in generating every possible melody.

Instead they applied an algorithm to 3 octaves, since going all-in with 88 keys and using all notes to make 10-note melody sequences would have produced technically unmanageable amounts of data.

โ€œI think musicians are too worried about substantial similarities without understanding how copyright works,โ€ French says.

He cites Neely as asking, โ€œcan you really copyright a four-note sequenceโ€ โ€“ and explains that if they sound similar and a jury finds them substantially similar โ€“ then yes, you can.

Can this be fixed by creating 68.7 billion melodies and registering them (under a Creative Commons permissive license)?

French says, no.

Melodies generated in this way donโ€™t meet the requirement of originality (though the algorithm that outputted them might); and crucially, copyright law allows two artists โ€œto create the same thing, as long as they didnโ€™t have access (โ€ฆ) copyright infringement means copying, or access and substantial similarity.โ€

And proving prior access to 68.7 billion melodies might get more than a little tricky.

In the end, French takes Neelyโ€™s video for what it is โ€“ โ€œa fun thought experiment to throw a wrench in the works of copyright.โ€

However, as he then observes, โ€œItโ€™s not even a wrench that the gears canโ€™t chew up. The machinery is made to deal with that problem by dismissing it from a lawsuit or claim.โ€

If you’re tired of censorship and surveillance, join Reclaim The Net.

Logo with a red shield enclosing a stylized globe and three red arrows pointing upward to the right, next to the text 'RECLAIM THE NET' with 'RECLAIM' in gray and 'THE NET' in red

Resist censorship. Reject surveillance. Reclaim your voice.

Support the exposure of censorship and surveillance, and protect your digital rights:

Logo with a red shield enclosing a stylized globe and three red arrows pointing upward to the right, next to the text 'RECLAIM THE NET' with 'RECLAIM' in gray and 'THE NET' in red

Resist censorship. Reject surveillance. Reclaim your voice.

Support the exposure of censorship and surveillance, and protect your digital rights:

Share this post