Freedom of Speech Requires Freedom of Reach

Why "freedom of speech, not freedom of reach" is a flawed argument.

Cindy Harper

X CEO Linda Yaccarino recently made headlines for talking out of both sides of her mouth. On the one hand she professes to be supporting free speech. On the other hand, she uses the tired, cliche, and sinister phrase of “freedom of speech but not freedom of reach,” one of the ways that has been used to justify censorship throughout history.

The policy is one where users, when posting narratives that are not in line with approved standards, are labeled, possibly demonetized for that content, and have their visibility reduced on the platform.

Become a Member and Keep Reading…

Reclaim your digital freedom. Get the latest on censorship, cancel culture, and surveillance, and learn how to fight back.

Already a supporter? Sign In.

(If you’re already logged in but still seeing this, refresh this page to show the post.)

Having trouble logging in? Get help here.

Read Next

How To: Ditching Your Phone Number Might Be the Smartest Privacy Move You Make

Read the story →

More you should know:

A halftone black-and-white hand holds a smartphone aloft beneath stylized concentric wireless-signal arcs on a bright orange background.

How To: Ditching Your Phone Number Might Be the Smartest Privacy Move You Make

Streaming service homepage showing a dark grid of movie thumbnails and category headings like "Audience and critic approved: 7.0+ on IMDb" and "New release movies," with visible posters for films including Superman, Guns Up, Jurassic World, Ballerina, How to Train Your Dragon, The Life of Chuck, Sinners, The Ruse, The Spinal Tap, The Meg, The Phoenician Scheme, and The Last Journey.

The “Buy” Button Is a Lie

Close-up of a weathered, cracked Statue of Liberty face in dramatic low-key lighting with its mouth tightly bound by a frayed blue band patterned with yellow stars, the fabric's texture and chipped paint clearly visible against a black background.

The Free Speech Standoff That’s Fracturing the Atlantic

A black-screen smartphone centered on a red, stippled background crowded with multiple large black-and-white eyes and curving red shapes.

Your Phone Isn’t Safe at the Border. Warrantless Phone Searches Hit Record High.

Stylized Earth showing North and South America formed from thousands of blue and orange streaks and glowing particles radiating outward against a black background.

DNS Becomes a Tool of Digital Rebellion: From Internet Infrastructure to Privacy Weapon

A halftone black-and-white hand holds a smartphone aloft beneath stylized concentric wireless-signal arcs on a bright orange background.

How To: Ditching Your Phone Number Might Be the Smartest Privacy Move You Make

Streaming service homepage showing a dark grid of movie thumbnails and category headings like "Audience and critic approved: 7.0+ on IMDb" and "New release movies," with visible posters for films including Superman, Guns Up, Jurassic World, Ballerina, How to Train Your Dragon, The Life of Chuck, Sinners, The Ruse, The Spinal Tap, The Meg, The Phoenician Scheme, and The Last Journey.

The “Buy” Button Is a Lie

Close-up of a weathered, cracked Statue of Liberty face in dramatic low-key lighting with its mouth tightly bound by a frayed blue band patterned with yellow stars, the fabric's texture and chipped paint clearly visible against a black background.

The Free Speech Standoff That’s Fracturing the Atlantic

A black-screen smartphone centered on a red, stippled background crowded with multiple large black-and-white eyes and curving red shapes.

Your Phone Isn’t Safe at the Border. Warrantless Phone Searches Hit Record High.

Stylized Earth showing North and South America formed from thousands of blue and orange streaks and glowing particles radiating outward against a black background.

DNS Becomes a Tool of Digital Rebellion: From Internet Infrastructure to Privacy Weapon

Students seated at desks using laptops and facing a blank projection screen in a classroom, shown from behind with colorful digital glitch overlays.

School Surveillance Is Criminalizing Speech